Best Hotels in Shelter Island

Enjoy hassle-free arrival and departure at Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach, where secure on-site parking ensures peace of mind during your stay. Say goodbye to parking stress as you easily access your accommodations after a day of exploration. Plus, with nearby attractions just minutes away, you can maximize your time enjoying everything Shelter Island Heights has to offer. Your seamless transit experience starts here, allowing you to focus on making memories.

Enjoy seamless arrival and peace of mind with convenient parking options at this waterfront resort. Designed to enhance your experience, the secure parking facilities ensure hassle-free transit throughout your stay. Whether you’re embarking on adventures around Shelter Island or simply exploring the local area, efficient and helpful parking solutions take the stress out of traveling. Focus on making memories while we handle the logistics of your visit.

Experience the ultimate nightlife at this vibrant resort on Shelter Island, where every evening comes alive with energy and excitement. Savor delicious cuisine at the all-American restaurant and unwind at the lively lounge, complete with stunning water views. Seasonal activities and events ensure there’s never a dull moment, making it a perfect spot for friends and couples seeking adventure and entertainment. Embrace the dynamic atmosphere and create unforgettable memories in this social paradise.

Experience the vibrant nightlife at Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach, where every evening transforms into a celebration! Just a stone's throw from Shelter Island Heights' lively spots, guests can dive into an array of activities that showcase local culture and excitement. With its chic contemporary art gallery and cozy communal spaces, this boutique B&B is your gateway to unforgettable evenings filled with music, laughter, and endless fun—perfect for social butterflies seeking adventure!

At Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach, your four-legged friends are more than welcome! This pet-friendly haven ensures no family member is left behind, featuring amenities tailored to keep your pets happy and comfortable. Enjoy leisurely walks along nearby scenic paths while creating unforgettable memories together. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, your vacation will be a truly inclusive experience for both you and your beloved pets.

The Pridwin Hotel is a haven for families seeking a safe and reassuring getaway on Shelter Island. With spacious accommodations and the option of private cottages, parents can relax while kids enjoy engaging seasonal activities designed to foster stress-free bonding. The hotel prioritizes safety and comfort, allowing families to explore nature together through hiking and boating. Create lasting memories in an environment tailored for both relaxation and fun!

Escape the crowds and indulge in the serene beauty of Shelter Island with direct access to soft sandy shores. This waterfront resort offers a tranquil retreat where guests can unwind on the beach, basking in the sun or enjoying peaceful strolls along the shoreline. Immerse yourself in nature's beauty while relishing the elite ambiance of private suites and cottages, ensuring a truly exclusive experience by the water's edge.

Rejuvenate your senses at the full-service spa, where wellness meets luxury in a serene setting. Guests can choose from signature treatments that melt away stress and promote relaxation, surrounded by the natural beauty of Shelter Island. Indulge in restorative therapies designed to refresh both body and mind, providing the perfect escape from daily life. Embrace tranquility and pamper yourself with a therapeutic experience that elevates your stay to new heights.