Best Hotels in Sanibel Island

Top Hotels in Sanibel Island

This guide to the best luxury, 5-star, and design-forward hotels in Sanibel Island is manually curated by our editorial team based on first-hand research, verified guest reviews, location analysis, and overall service quality. Each hotel is selected to meet high standards of comfort, authenticity, and guest experience.

Island Inn
Hotels

This Southern Florida hotel is located on 10 acres of Sanibel Island. It has 550 feet of private beach as well as onsite bicycle, kayak and paddleboard rentals. All rooms at the island Inn have a seating area, HD cable smart TVs, and full kitchens. a view of the ocean, free Wi-Fi, and an iPod docking station is also provided. The Island Inn's private beach provides an excellent area for swimming, BQQ grilling and seashell collecting. The front desk staff can also help guests organize sailing or kayaking expeditions. The Island Inn is 5 minute's drive from the 5,200-acre J. N. Darling Wildlife Refuge and less than 22 miles from Fort Myers city Center. Jerrys Grocery Store is less than 3 miles away. Front Desk Hours are 8 am EST to 5 pm EST daily. If guests are arriving after 5 pm EST they need to contact the hotel directly for after hours instructions. Construction will be going on in other areas of the property daily from 9 am EST to 5 pm EST

Guest Reviews:

- "It was wonderful, far more than expected." - "We had a great time very relaxing and will definitely be going back again." - "Excellent however the bites are horrendous" - "Beautiful weather, beautiful water" - "Nice but not like expected"

Sundial Beach Resort & Spa
Hotels

Offering a Gulf-front spa, outdoor pool, and free WiFi access, this beachfront Sanibel, Florida resort is 3.5 mi from the Sanibel Lighthouse. Sundial Beach Resort & Spa offers ocean kayaks, paddleboards, and 16 pickleball courts. Units have a kitchen with an oven, stovetop, refrigerator, microwave, and coffee-making facilities for guests’ convenience. A cable TV and a seating area are also featured in all accommodations at Sundial Beach Resort. In addition, Sundial Beach Resort & Spa has 16 pickleball courts. Four restaurants and 2 bars with outdoor and indoor dining are on site. Four tennis courts, beach volleyball, and an organized activities program are offered. A lessons and tours is available. J. N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge is located 11 minutes’ drive from the property, Sanibel city center is 2.9 mi away from the hotel, and Sanibel Historical Museum and Village is 3.2 mi away. Upon resort reopening, it is important to note that there initially may be active construction around the island and at some resort accommodations buildings. For your safety, please be mindful of any restricted and signed areas both around the island and at the resort. Please also note that elevators may not be available in every building; please contact reservations at 866.565.5093 for details. Our island community has made incredible hurricane recovery strides and continues to push forward with full recovery efforts, and we are delighted to welcome you back to our home.

Sanibel Island Hotels with Parking

best hotels in Sanibel Island
9.0
117 reviews
From $399

Experience hassle-free transit at Island Inn, where efficient parking solutions ensure a seamless arrival and departure. Guests can rest easy knowing their vehicles are secure in a well-maintained area. With convenient access to local attractions, explore the picturesque Sanibel Island without the stress of parking woes. Enjoy peace of mind as you focus on creating unforgettable memories with family and friends in this welcoming Southern Florida destination.

Sanibel Island Family Friendly Hotels

best hotels in Sanibel Island
9.0
117 reviews
From $399

At Island Inn, families can enjoy a reassuring retreat designed for stress-free bonding and adventure. The dedicated kids' club ensures little ones are entertained while parents relax, knowing their children are in a safe environment. Spacious accommodations with full kitchens allow for home-cooked meals together, enhancing the family experience. With nearby activities like kayaking and seashell collecting, every day offers opportunities for cherished memories and fun-filled moments under the sun.

Sanibel Island Hotels with Private Beach

best hotels in Sanibel Island
9.0
117 reviews
From $399

Escape to the serene shores of Island Inn, where direct access to 550 feet of pristine private beach awaits. Feel the soft sand beneath your toes as you unwind away from crowded tourist spots. This elite beachfront haven invites guests to indulge in leisurely days of swimming, BBQ grilling, and collecting beautiful seashells. Experience the tranquility of the ocean's gentle waves, making it the perfect escape for those seeking relaxation and luxury amid nature's beauty.

Sanibel Island Hotels with Entertainment

best hotels in Sanibel Island
6.5
40 reviews
From $809

Dive into a vibrant nightlife at this exciting beachfront resort! With four restaurants and two lively bars, guests can savor delicious cuisine and sip refreshing cocktails while enjoying stunning ocean views. Engage in thrilling activities like beach volleyball or explore the waters with complimentary kayaks and paddleboards. The 16 pickleball courts promise endless fun and friendly competition for all ages, ensuring your stay is filled with energy and unforgettable memories.

Sanibel Island Hotels with Spa

Map