Top Boutique Hotels in Long Island (2026)

Located in Port Washington, 10 miles from Belmont Park Race Track, Fathoms Hotel & Marina has accommodations with a garden, free private parking, a shared lounge and a terrace. Offering a bar, the property is located within 12 miles of Citi Field. Guests can have a drink at the snack bar. At the hotel, all rooms are equipped with a closet. Complete with a private bathroom equipped with a shower and free toiletries, all rooms at Fathoms Hotel & Marina have a flat-screen TV and air conditioning, and certain rooms also offer a balcony. At the accommodation the rooms are equipped with bed linen and towels. Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum is 13 miles from Fathoms Hotel & Marina, while Arthur Ashe Stadium is 14 miles from the property. The nearest airport is LaGuardia Airport, 12 miles from the hotel.

Located in the Village of Amagansett, Town of East Hampton, The Roundtree, Amagansett features free bikes, garden, BBQ facilities, and free WiFi. Free Private Parking is available at the property. Guest rooms are equipped with air conditioning, a flat-screen TV with cable channels, a coffee machine, a shower, a hairdryer and a desk. At the hotel each room has a wardrobe and a private bathroom. Montauk is 11 mi from The Roundtree, Amagansett, while East Hampton is 2.7 mi away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 55 mi from the accommodations.

- "This place is an authentic paradise. Perfect staff with good service. The place itself is perfectly curated." - "Separate cabins are wonderful. Ours was tastefully decorated and was stocked with free snacks, free beverages including Nespresso coffee machine." - "We loved the cosy, luxurious and beautiful property with a bit of history. The hotel staff were very kind and helpful. Would love to keep coming back." - "Friendly, clean, elegant"

Located in Greenport and with Splish Splash reachable within 26 miles, The Menhaden Hotel has concierge services, allergy-free rooms, free bikes, free WiFi throughout the property and a terrace. Featuring a bar, the 4-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with a private bathroom. The property provides a 24-hour front desk and luggage storage space for guests. At the hotel, rooms are equipped with a closet. The rooms in The Menhaden Hotel are equipped with a flat-screen TV and free toiletries. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 47 miles from the accommodation.

- "amenities were fantastic from bar, to hot croissants and cookies to bathroom soap! front desk staff was so friendly and had great recommendations. Really easy to hop over to shelter island as the ferry was right by the hotel" - "The property was clean, beautiful, and the customer service was immaculate! Felicia was amazing and really made us feel welcome!" - "Clean , beautiful and so many extras" - "Great location. Awesome staff. Great little extras that made it special."

Located in Quogue, 1.9 miles from Rogers Beach, The Quogue Club provides accommodations with a fitness center, free private parking, a garden and a shared lounge. Featuring a bar, the 5-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi, each with a private bathroom. The property has a 24-hour front desk and a concierge service for guests. At the hotel, every room includes a closet. All guest rooms in The Quogue Club are equipped with a flat-screen TV and free toiletries. At the accommodation you'll find a restaurant serving American cuisine. Dairy-free, vegan and gluten-free options can also be requested. Guests at The Quogue Club will be able to enjoy activities in and around Quogue, like cycling. Splish Splash is 13 miles from the hotel, while Agawam Park is 14 miles away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 27 miles from The Quogue Club.

- "The complimentary breakfast was exquisite." - "It was wonderful." - "Accommodations FOOD" - "Stunning decor, super comfy, delicious breakfast!" - "Nice Building and facilities. The room was tiny, perhaps the smallest room I’ve ever had to stay in!! And for that alone I would not go back. The staff were all friendly and helpful, food excellent, fantastic gym in the basement, free bicycle use, and free beach pass and beach chairs, etc, to a private club beach one mile away. I paid $2900 for 3 nights and stayed in the smallest room ever, so not worth the money."

Providing elegant all-suite accommodations furnished with fully equipped kitchens, this Woodbury, New York hotel is located on the North Shore of Long Island and is surrounded by local attractions. Free Wi-Fi is provided to all guests. Guests at The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel are offered a daily full American breakfast. Complimentary dinner is served from Mondays through Thursdays (excluding holidays).. An on-site Bar and Lounge is located off the main reception. Lounge by the outdoor swimming pool or relax in the outdoor courtyard, complete with beautiful gardens. Enjoy in-room flat-screen TVs. Additional amenities at Fox Hollow include a 24-hour fitness center and on-site boutiques. The on-site award-winning Volpe Restaurant and Lounge serves Italian cuisine for dinner. The bar area is open 7 days a week. Guests at The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel can discover a number of historic sites, local shopping centers and top-rated golf courses in the surrounding areas. A wine country and scenic hiking trails are also available nearby. Central Melville is 10 minutes' drive away.

- "Charming boutique hotel. Very home like feeling for our Christmas stay" - "I stayed here for 5 nights while on business. I liked the friendly atmosphere and found all the staff to be delightful. The room was large, comfortable and clean while the food both for breakfast and dinner was excellent. I was really pleased with the complimentary shuttle service - you could request a ride to anywhere within 10 miles or so of the hotel. I really enjoyed talking with the various drivers over the 5 days and this service really was icing on the cake. I would certainly stay again."

Featuring an on-site restaurant and seasonal saltwater swimming pool, Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York. Free WiFi is accessible throughout the property and free private parking is available on site. Each guest room has a flat-screen cable TV and a refrigerator. The private bathrooms include bathrobes and free toiletries. Select rooms offer views of the sea or garden. Guests at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor are greeted at the 24-hour front desk. Clothing, accessories, and refreshments are available at The Dock Shop. The dining room serves fresh American cuisine and is open daily for lunch and dinner. Breakfast and brunch are available on the weekend. Bike hire is available at this hotel and the area is popular for cycling. Mystic is 30 mi from Baron's Cove, while Montauk is 18 mi away.

- "The gym" - "I was at Baron's Cove for a short 1 day visit with my daughter to attend a local event. Staff was excellent; both over the phone and in person. They went above and beyond to make sure that my room was available for an early check in. The room and all amenities were great and well thought of. The room decor was cute and the room didn't smell like a musty hotel. The bed was super comfortable. I would definitely recommend Baron's Cove to anyone wanting a nice getaway."

Located just off Route 27, The Montauk Beach House features an outdoor swimming pool, gift shop, café and snack bar. Free Wi-Fi access is available. A flat-screen cable TV is included in each air conditioned guest room. The private bathrooms are equipped with free toiletries. Select rooms have a pool view. Guests can relax poolside or enjoy cocktails in the lounge. There is a DJ on-site every weekend. Clothing, beauty products and more are available in the gift shop. The Beach House in Montauk has a 24-hour front desk. A selection of small plates and sandwiches are available at the café and outdoor grill. Additional dining options including South Edison are located within walking distance. Camp Hero State Park is 4.3 mi away and Hither Hills State Park is 5.8 mi away.

- "I absolutely love the pool even thou the temperature was in the low 70’s , and a bit windy , the pool was perfect nice , clean and warm. The pool staff were always checkin in to refill my drink . You can’t bring drinks or food from The outside to the pool area. They have everything . Also I loved the chill , nice music the played throughout the day. I heard they have live music on Saturdays, next year I’ll try to come back and stay longer." - "Loved the location, the car transfer service, the staff, the pool"

The Garden City Hotel features 272 guest rooms and suites. The property is located in Long Island’s Garden City, in New York. A seasonal outdoor dining area is featured on site. All rooms feature custom millwork and Italian furniture, plush pillow top mattresses, mini refrigerators and bathrooms with French boutique amenities. The penthouse rooms and suites boast balconies overlooking the village of Garden City. Every room features technology for connecting all mobile devices. At this property, guests can enjoy a 24-hour fitness center and an indoor pool from 7AM to 7PM. The Wine Room offers a private dining space for events, meetings and celebrations. The seasonal Patio Bar serves refreshing cocktails. The on-site Red Salt Room by David Burke, restaurant serves steaks, chops and signature entrées. The King Bar by David Burke, offers a bar menu, scratch-made cocktails and an extensive wine list. This hotel is located across from the Long Island Railroad which provides access to New York City and its major airports.

- "Room and lobby" - "I have never stayed at this hotel in my life and I have lived in long island my whole life.... when I say this hotel deserves TEN STARS!!!! It's the best! The customer service was 🔥 the rooms are BEAUTIFUL and spacious, they even have a personal loung on SITE of the hotel, a store that they open up for you within the hotel when requested and they have a restaurant!!! Their Valet staff are professional and everyone treats you with respect. The beds are comfortable out of this world! I cant WAIT to stay here again and i HIGHLY recommend this hotel to EVERYONE!!! GREAT JOB GARDEN CITY HOTEL!!!"

Set on more than 5 acres of beautifully landscaped lawns, this Long Island hotel features a modern American restaurant with poolside service. Free summer transportation to Cooper’s Beach is available. Rooms at the Southampton Inn feature seashore themes and are equipped with free WiFi and cable TV. An in-room refrigerator and a work desk are included. Located on site, Claude's offers breakfast, brunch and dinner meals made from fresh, local ingredients. Summer meals are also served in the courtyard and dining room. Southampton Inn guests are welcome to enjoy the outdoor pool, tennis court and library. A games room and children’s play area offers video games, toys and board games. The Inn at Southampton is less than 2.5 mi from Southampton Golf Course and less than 9.3 mi from the Morton National Wildlife Refuge.

- "I have stayed at many places in Southampton. This place was great. Parking right out front. Rooms are large bright and clean. Bathroom is a good size. Beds very comfortable and nice bedding. Water and coffee maker. Toiletries. Lobby with fireplace and staff very friendly. Walking distance to everything in Southampton. It was a pleasure." - "I have stayed here several times. The place is always immaculate the rooms are well decorated and you have everything you need."

Located in East Hampton, 1.1 miles from Indian Wells Beach, Journey East Hampton provides accommodations with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a garden and a shared lounge. Located around 1.1 miles from Egypt Beach, the hotel with free WiFi is also 1.1 miles away from Two Mile Hollow Beach. Hither Woods Preserve is 13 miles from the hotel and Fort Pond Bay Park is 14 miles away. At the hotel, all rooms are equipped with a closet. Complete with a private bathroom equipped with a shower and free toiletries, all guest rooms at Journey East Hampton have a flat-screen TV and air conditioning, and some rooms come with a seating area. All rooms will provide guests with a fridge. Montauk Point Lighthouse is 6.6 miles from the accommodation, while Second House Museum is 12 miles away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 53 miles from Journey East Hampton.

- "Charming motel decorated with taste. The lobby is a very nice place to chill ." - "Landscape, lobby,pool stairs, look and feel." - "The facilities at the hotel were amazing, with charming rooms and incredibly comfortable bedding. We loved that they offered bikes for rent, which allowed us to explore the nearby beach at our leisure. In the evenings, the firepit with s'mores from 6-9 added a delightful touch to our stay." - "Rooms were stylish, large and comfortable."